Review

18Rhl

18Rhl offers two maps with clearly different priorities, but it does not do much to refresh the familiar 18XX formula. RHL is agreeably manageable, though its competition for the right networks is tighter than it needs to be.

18Rhl

18Rhl

Published
2024
Designer
Wolfram Janich
Publisher
Fox in the Box, Marflow Games
Players
2–5
Playing time
360 min

Fox in the Box’s 18Rhl is an 18XX built as two games in one: RHL and LRA, with separate maps and rule sets. The premise is neat and the execution is serviceable, but this is not a design trying to rewrite the formula; it is more a rearrangement of familiar furniture.

In RHL, which I played with four, the emphasis is on building one genuinely strong company and developing a network around the river. LRA shifts towards a more direct connect-the-dots exercise, with the ports serving as the network’s obvious destinations. The interesting decision is whether to invest in the quality and extraction value of one network, or race towards the connections that matter.

The interesting decision is whether to invest in the quality and extraction value of one network, or race towards the connections that matter.
TheTrainSpotter

The trains are effectively all express, so villages become prizes rather than places to skip. Privates are less powerful, and the lack of a 60% ownership limit lets you load up a company and milk it; meanwhile, the small supply of useful advanced tiles makes laying track distinctly unforgiving, because a careless early decision can leave you outside the worthwhile networks. Mercifully, the ceiling of a 6-train keeps the arithmetic reasonable, a point my spreadsheet was only too ready to confirm.

Its running time is sensible and RHL was an agreeable play, but the narrow tile choices feel more like a restriction than elegant pressure. 18Rhl is good, but there are plainly better routes through this particular territory.

18Rhl is good, but there are plainly better routes through this particular territory.
TheTrainSpotter

Source: BoardGameGeek

0 comments

Read on

All reviews →
  • Review Red Dust Rebellion

    Red Dust Rebellion may be the most demanding COIN I have played, and perhaps the best. Its wildly asymmetrical factions look liable to collapse into nonsense; instead, they form an unusually well-balanced whole.

    TheTrainSpotter · 25 Aug 2026
  • Review Imperial Borders

    Imperial Borders takes Napoleonic warfare and turns it into a cleaner, more symmetrical wargame rather than a historical simulation. We did not complete a full game, but the preparation, demonstrations, and lengthy opening analysis made a persuasive case.

    TheTrainSpotter · 25 Aug 2026
  • Review Phoenix New Horizon

    A knotty worker-placement euro with engine building, a touch of area majority, and more player friction than the genre usually permits. Perfectly competent, though its turn-order system keeps it short of excellence.

    TheTrainSpotter · 22 Jul 2026

More by TheTrainSpotter →