Review

Black Clover: Star Festival

A light hidden-squad-placement game of magical knights, missions, and dice that reminded me of Argent: the Consortium in a much simpler form. It has an interesting foundation, but its player interaction is not as developed as I wanted it to be.

Black Clover: Star Festival

Black Clover: Star Festival

Published
2025
Designer
Dylan Birtolo, Josh Derksen
Publisher
Japanime Games
Players
2–4

I picked up Black Clover: Star Festival for reasons I cannot entirely defend even myself. I do not know the manga it is based on, but hidden squad placement was enough bait: after the unforgettable Mechanisburgo, anything that hides teams and intentions beneath that kind of system immediately gets my attention.

Each player takes charge of a team of magical knights at the annual magic festival, aiming to complete missions. Your team moves between different locations, while a rudimentary bit of deck building along the way adds some development to your choices without making the game especially heavy.

Then come the missions, where the luck of the dice gets a say, alongside a rather polite form of conflict with the other players. Character powers can affect other players, so there is theoretically room for interference and little reversals; in practice, though, this side of the game feels like it needed more care.

Overall, it is a light game with something to say, and it brought the also very good Argent: the Consortium to mind, only in a noticeably lighter form. Still, the powers that reach over to affect other players did not convince me that they have been developed enough. If the friction between players does not kick in, the festival can very easily turn into dice-gambling solitaire — at which point the magical knights are left doing their own thing, merely at the same table.

Source: BoardGameGeek

0 comments

Read on

All reviews →
  • Phoenix New Horizon

    Phoenix New Horizon is a somewhat kinky worker-placement euro with plenty of engine building and slightly more interaction than the genre usually offers. It is not bad at all, but its turn-order mechanism left me annoyed, especially at four players.

    TheCuttlefish · 22 Jul 2026
  • Knee Deep in Hexes

    A fair, zero-luck game for two that brings the tension of a classic resource-rush RTS to the table. Its rules are simple, but it is far more cunning than it first appears.

    TheCuttlefish · 22 Jul 2026
  • Lairs

    Lairs is Battleship with dungeons, monsters, and loot: a clever game with an asymmetric idea and a wonderfully light mood. The base box works nicely for younger players, while any expansion opens it up for older ones too.

    TheCuttlefish · 22 Jul 2026

More by TheCuttlefish →