Review

Carson City: Big Box

Carson City: Big Box came back to the table with horses and an aggressively combative character mix, and promptly reminded us why it made such a strong first impression. Nobody was allowed a quiet little corner of the West.

Carson City: Big Box

Carson City: Big Box

Published
2015
Designer
Xavier Georges
Publisher
Emperor Penguin Games, Maldito Games, Mosaico Jogos
Players
2–6
Playing time
180 min

Carson City: Big Box is one of those games that impresses immediately, then somehow spends far too long on the shelf. Bring it back out, let it spread across the table, and the memory returns quickly: this is not a game for peacefully tending your own patch of territory.

We used the horse variant, which gave the game a different pace and new lines of movement. More importantly, we had a particularly aggressive mix of characters. Choosing characters was not polite preparation for the round; it was the opening move in a fight, because every useful option seemed to come with someone across the table ready to turn it against you.

With this character mix, the table became a battlefield.
TheCuttlefish

The game moved through its rounds as a proper contest of position and timing. You try to advance your own plan, but the other players are not background scenery: they block, squeeze, and force you to keep asking who is holding the next nasty move. With this character mix, the table became a battlefield. Quite rightly, too.

Then hida did what a player can do when, unusually, they are not already ahead before the finish: he saved his strength and sprinted through the final round, farming the rest of us. It was an excellent game, full of pressure and collisions, with everyone leaving a little bruised and thoroughly pleased. Carson City: Big Box does not merely ask you to play well; it asks whether you can survive the other players.

Carson City: Big Box does not merely ask you to play well; it asks whether you can survive the other players.
TheCuttlefish

Source: BoardGameGeek

0 comments

Read on

All reviews →
  • Review SpaceCorp: 2025-2300AD

    SpaceCorp with Ventures is a tight, lively full package, and it is notably better at three, where blocking and close scores make every move matter. You may complain before realising how dangerous your company becomes in the final phase; that is part of the pleasure.

    TheCuttlefish · 25 Aug 2026
  • Review Knee Deep in Hexes

    Knee Deep in Hexes is an honest, luck-free duel with the urgent economy of a classic resource-rush RTS. The rules are light, but repeat games develop teeth.

    TheCuttlefish · 22 Jul 2026
  • Review Arcs

    Arcs improves markedly once the advanced rules, asymmetric alien factions, and their powers enter the picture. It still leaves too much of its balance to the people around the table, but this is no longer an automatic no.

    TheCuttlefish · 22 Jul 2026

More by TheCuttlefish →