Review

Viscounts of the West Kingdom

Viscounts of the West Kingdom turns a rondel into something less predictable and, consequently, more compelling. The shifting card supply blunts long-range planning, but it does not blunt the design.

Viscounts of the West Kingdom

Viscounts of the West Kingdom

Published
2020
Designer
S J Macdonald, Shem Phillips
Publisher
Garphill Games, Banana Games, CMON Global Limited
Players
1–4
Playing time
90 min

Viscounts of the West Kingdom occupies an odd position in the series: familiar euro machinery, arranged so that it never settles into routine. Its modified rondel has proper character. It creates decisions with consequence rather than simply providing a route through an already-solved turn.

A turn moves through that rondel, and each location presents a different set of cards whenever it is visited. That variability is where the luck lives, but it is also where the game earns its texture: it does not reward memorising a sequence so much as adapting to the tools currently on offer.

The interesting decision is how far ahead you can plan without becoming attached to the plan.
TheTrainSpotter

The interesting decision is how far ahead you can plan without becoming attached to the plan. By the time your turn returns, the board may have shifted enough to make your intended move distinctly second-best; player interaction comes through that instability in the shared space. Even the committed heavy-euro calculator will occasionally find that the neat continuation has evaporated.

That friction is not a flaw to be apologised for. Viscounts is, without doubt, the best game in the West Kingdom series. The expansion makes more sense as a separate experiment, while Tomesaga is stronger without expansions; the base game here is already complete, and quietly excellent.

Viscounts is, without doubt, the best game in the West Kingdom series.
TheTrainSpotter

Source: BoardGameGeek

0 comments

Read on

All reviews →
  • Review Red Dust Rebellion

    Red Dust Rebellion may be the most demanding COIN I have played, and perhaps the best. Its wildly asymmetrical factions look liable to collapse into nonsense; instead, they form an unusually well-balanced whole.

    TheTrainSpotter · 25 Aug 2026
  • Review Imperial Borders

    Imperial Borders takes Napoleonic warfare and turns it into a cleaner, more symmetrical wargame rather than a historical simulation. We did not complete a full game, but the preparation, demonstrations, and lengthy opening analysis made a persuasive case.

    TheTrainSpotter · 25 Aug 2026
  • Review Phoenix New Horizon

    A knotty worker-placement euro with engine building, a touch of area majority, and more player friction than the genre usually permits. Perfectly competent, though its turn-order system keeps it short of excellence.

    TheTrainSpotter · 22 Jul 2026

More by TheTrainSpotter →